When It’s Real by Erin Watt – A Celebrity Romance Worth the Hype

Are you a fan of contemporary romance with a splash of Hollywood drama? When It’s Real by Erin Watt delivers all the glitz, angst, and unexpected emotions you’d want in a fake-dating love story. Dive into this compelling New Adult novel that combines the chaotic world of celebrity culture with the grounded perspective of an everyday teenage girl.

Overview of When It’s Real

Author: Erin Watt
Genre: Contemporary Romance, New Adult, Celebrity Fiction
Release Date: May 2017

Plot Summary

Oakley Ford has it all—chart-topping music hits, red carpet appearances, and an army of devoted fans. But underneath the fame lies a troubled teen star losing his artistic spark and battling a tarnished reputation. With the media scrutinizing his every move, his management team plans a complete image makeover—including a fake relationship.

Enter Vaughn Bennett, a 17-year-old waitress with no interest in the spotlight. But with bills piling up and her family’s future on the line, she reluctantly agrees to the role of Oakley’s “girlfriend.” Her mission? Pretend to be in love with the pop sensation, smile for the cameras, and survive the glittering chaos of fame.

But as time passes, lines between fake and real begin to blur. Is there more to Oakley than just a spoiled rockstar persona? And can Vaughn protect her heart in a world built on appearances?

---

What Makes When It’s Real Stand Out?

1. Relatable Characters in an Unreal World

Oakley may be a global superstar, but his inner turmoil makes him surprisingly human. He’s cocky, yes—but also vulnerable, insecure, and searching for meaning beyond his fame. Vaughn, on the other hand, is refreshing. She’s practical, loyal, and grounded—a stark contrast to Oakley’s world of excess.

Their chemistry feels real, and the tension between them drives the story forward in an addictive way.

2. Fake Dating Trope – Done Right

Erin Watt breathes new life into the classic fake dating trope. There’s playful banter, slow-burn attraction, and emotional conflict that feels authentic. Readers who enjoy romantic tension and reluctant love stories will appreciate how their relationship evolves naturally over time.

3. Hollywood Meets Heartfelt Drama

From glamorous parties to private meltdowns, the book offers a peek behind the curtain of celebrity life. It doesn’t shy away from showing the price of fame—loneliness, manipulation, and pressure. But it also highlights genuine connections, family loyalty, and the importance of staying true to yourself.

---

Reading Experience: Pacing, Style, and Voice

Erin Watt’s writing is sharp, accessible, and filled with humor. The alternating POVs between Oakley and Vaughn give readers insight into both worlds, making the story feel layered and emotionally rich. The pacing is fast, making this a perfect weekend or beach read.

Fans of Watt’s previous works, like Paper Princess, will find the same addictive quality in When It’s Real, but with more heart and less drama-fueled chaos.

---

Who Should Read When It’s Real?

This book is ideal for:

• Readers who enjoy contemporary New Adult romance

• Fans of celebrity love stories and fake relationships

• Anyone who loved titles like To All the Boys I’ve Loved Before, Famous in Love, or Between the Lines

It’s also great for those who want a story that balances drama with emotional depth and character growth.

---

Final Verdict: A Glamorous Yet Grounded Romance

When It’s Real is more than just a celebrity love story—it’s about finding authenticity in a world built on illusions. With endearing characters, swoon-worthy moments, and an honest look at fame’s impact, Erin Watt has crafted a romance that’s both fun and unexpectedly emotional.

Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.5/5)
Whether you’re in it for the glam or the heart, this is one YA-to-NA crossover you won’t want to miss.

---

More Books Like When It’s Real

If you enjoyed this story, check out these similar reads:

• Between the Lines by Tammara Webber – A behind-the-scenes love story set in Hollywood.

• Famous by Default by M.K. Harkins – Another take on fame, fake dating, and discovering what’s real.

Looking for your next celebrity romance fix? When It’s Real should be at the top of your list.